The remaining 11 women and Ben relocated from Utah to Puerto Rico for a week of dates for all! That means two 1:1 dates and 1 group date. There is still tension between sweet Emily and psychopath lip-puckerer Courtney, which Courtney classily gives voice to, saying, “You better check yourself, bitch.” Who knew that model Courtney was a fan of that 1993 Ice Cube masterwork? I much prefer Ice Cube’s vastly underrated “Bop Gun,” but to each her own! Also, you’re a terrible person and your ex waxes his chest, Courtney.
Nicki (brunette, dental hygienist (OF COURSE SHE IS), TX native) gets the first 1:1 and gets all dolled up in a cute, one-shoulder dress and wedges. I approve! Ben and Nicki walk around the downtown area of Vieques Island and get caught in a flash rainstorm. The two are soaked and running through the streets, clutching their shoes. Didn’t this happen in “The Bachelorette” last season, between Ashley and Ben? Tough memories for ‘ole Benny Flanny. Or wait, perhaps that was a scene between Ashley and Constantine (a Ben look-alike and one half of the Ben/Constantine duo that I nicknamed “The Monkey Twins”)? Either way, Ben and Nicki are soaked and now they must buy new, traditional Puerto Rican clothing. As Nicki said, “Nothing can rain on this parade!” (Barf.) Ben is impressed that Nicki can just roll with this turn of events, but what choice does she have? Get upset because it rained and go back to the white girl compound? Nicki buys a cute (but somewhat unflattering) scarf dress and flats (just say no to flats!) and Ben draws inspiration from “Scarface” with his all-white ensemble.
Ben & Nicki walk around in their new duds and stumble upon a wedding just as the bride is entering the church from the street. There’s no better way to upstage a bride than roll up with a reality TV camera crew and film the conversation that your young lovers are having JUST OUTSIDE a wedding. This scene prompts a discussion of marriage and Nicki explains that while she’s divorced, she still believes in marriage and wants to remarry. Later they change clothes (again) and enjoy dinner and cocktails by the beach. Ben makes yet another odd fashion choice (for those keeping track at home, so far we have WAY too many vests going on and that all-white “cocaine kingpin” ensemble): suspenders, but he doesn’t use them to hold up his pants—they’re just for show. Yes, suspenders just hanging around his bum. Fashion hasn’t been so dysfunctional since the 1990s when we all wore overalls with 1 or 2 straps pulled down. (DON’T LIE—you know you did it, too.) Nicki scores a rose.
Up next is a group date for everyone except Elyse (which means that she’ll FINALLY get a 1:1 date). The date card says, “Diamonds are a girl’s best friend,” but this isn’t a reference to “Gentlemen Prefer Blondes” OR to the De Beers diamonds antitrust legislation (they were/are price-fixing diamonds! Diamonds aren’t a rarity at all—seriously!) OR to the film “Blood Diamond,” but rather, BASEBALL DIAMONDS. Baseball south of the border—break out the cornrows and get Stevie in here cause this feels like season 2 of “East Bound & Down”! The 9 women arrive at Gigantes stadium (Puerto Rico’s beloved baseball team) and spend the afternoon training with 3 Gigantes coaches and Ben. Blakeley has amazing softball skills and explains that she played softball in high school and college. Courtney says the only funny/non-psychopathic thing that she has ever said, “Who knew that strippers could play baseball?”
Chris Harrison informs the ladies that they’ll be playing a softball game against each other that night. Each team will have 4 members, with Ben as permanent pitcher and one lady playing for both teams (insert bisexuality joke here). The winning team’s prize will be a beach-side after party with plenty of booze and Ben. Ben gets to pick a girl to be the swing (play for both teams) and he selects Lindzi (aka bronzer overdose). The two teams are:
Courtney (Satanic captain)
Casey S (her sidekick who always does her bidding, but has cool hair)
Kaci B (poor man’s Minka Kelly whose hair is super kinky in the tropics)
Jamie (sweetheart girl whose clothing is beyond cheesy)
Blakeley (Stripper captain)
Emily (blonde girl who Ben scolded for having an opinion in the last episode)
Jennifer (redhead accountant)
Rachel (NYC-based blonde)
Their intended 2 inning game (only 2 innings?) goes into extra innings because of a tie, until finally Jennifer strikes out and the red team wins. In a move that’s Kenny Powers-esque on the insensitivity scale, Ben and the red team then spray champagne all over the baseball diamond and hop into a helicopter. The blue team boards the loser school bus and heads home.
Ben and the red team clean up for the “after party” during which Ben gives Kaci B. (poor man’s Minka) a rose. Watching Courtney watch Kaci B. score a rose and a kiss was music to my eyes (if that’s a thing). Courtney has some alone time with Ben, during which she shows a whole lotta side boob and says that they should go skinny dipping sometime. FORESHADOWING!
The next day, Ben picks up Chicago-based personal trainer Elyse for her long-awaited 1:1 date. I’ve always liked Elyse—great hair, good taste in clothes (fantastic one-shoulder dresses), and big earrings. A girl after my own heart. But once she begins talking to Ben, I can see why he’s just not feeling it. She sounds like a valley girl and she has an almost Snooki-like quality to her. After they spend time swimming and jumping off a yacht, they clean up and eat a candlelit dinner on the beach. Ben makes a toast to them being the best-dressed people on the (empty) beach, and Elyse doesn’t seem to get it. Their conversation feels like a job interview—no chemistry or romance there. Nonetheless, Ben picks up the rose from the plate (as though he’s going to give it to her), but then proceeds to explain that he’s sending her home. Harsh! I’m not totally surprised, though. Elyse was a little slow out of the gate and Ben has already forged connections with some of the other ladies. Poor Elyse asks what she did wrong, and I yelled at my TV, “Nothing! You just weren’t pushy and you didn’t throw yourself at him! These aren’t bad things!” She hops into a motorboat and is whisked away, never to be seen again (until the “Women Tell All” when she’ll probably show up as a redhead or a blonde, because that’s usually what happens).
Ben tosses the unused rose in the ocean (those Bachelor producers are all about subtle symbolism) and walks back to his hotel room, where single-white-female, fatal attraction Courtney is waiting for him on the stairs. Woa. You two are going skinny dipping whether he likes it or not. Courtney has a bottle of wine and two glasses (in an attempt to seem less stalker-y?) and they walk down the beach, strip naked, then hop in the surf. What a classy way for Ben to spend the hours after he has sent a crying woman home. Apparently “nice guy” Ben isn’t so nice at all, and is easily swayed by a skeletal body and pursed lips.
Cut to the cocktail party the next night. Nobody knows about Courtney and Ben’s skinny dipping, but Courtney keeps bringing up skinny dipping in conversation with the other girls. What a hilarious inside joke with yourself, Courtney! Did you learn your social skills from a crew of 5th grade mean girls? Ben says to the camera that he and Courtney had an “intimate moment” and now he regrets it. Later, he has some good 1:1 conversations with the ladies. During her time, Emily mentions again that Courtney is very different around Ben than she is around everyone else, and Ben tells Emily to, “be careful.” Wow. That’s ALMOST as offensive as being told to “simmer down.” If I were on this show, I would have walked at that point. Then again, I’m not known for my calmness in the face of frustration, so please don’t heed my advice. In Blakeley and Ben’s 1:1 time, she tells him that every day she writes down 1 good thing about Ben in her journal and somehow that’s teaching her that she deserves love. Huh? How about you write down 1 good thing about YOU, girl. Love yourself before you love anybody else.
Finally, it’s rose ceremony time and the order is: Lindzi, Jamie (cheese ball sweetheart is still flying under the radar!), Rachel, Courtney (the master of darkness), Casey S. (I guess she and Courtney are a package deal now)
Blakeley and finally, Emily (she’s being punished for having opinions AGAIN). Redheaded accountant Jennifer is going home and she’s pretty upset. She was ranked best kisser once upon a time! But just last week I said that she was normal and chill, and thus she’d be gone soon. And so it goes.
Up next, the group is heading to the country that was invented by Van Halen: PANAMA!